Standardized Confusion

I apologize to my non-US readers in advance, but you might find this interesting, too. The next time you have 18 minutes and need a good laugh, have a look at this video from John Oliver regarding standardized testing in the US’s public schools. This comes with a language advisory.

Funny? I thought it was a riot. At the same time, it’s disturbing. Two-thirds of my property tax bill goes to support my county’s schools, and it sounds like a good amount of that money goes to pay companies with a vested interest in testing kids continually, as required by Federal law. And it sounds like the teachers are under undue pressure to make sure that the students show progress on the tests administered by states under Federal law. So much so, in fact, that recently eleven teachers and administrators of the Atlanta Public Schools were handed fines and prison sentences for their part in a cheating scandal involving the standardized tests they were ordered to administer by the state Board of Education. Federal funding for the state’s schools is dependent on showing that the students are progressing. So there’s a lot of money involved.

But even worse than all of that is the mental and emotional pressure the kids are under with all of the standardized testing. I mean, kids are throwing up in the middle of tests. They’re taking tests constantly. Is it really showing anyone in this country that the kids are learning? Do they even have time to learn anything, with all the testing they have to deal with?

I realize that students in the US are starting to show poorly on the international stage, and it’s embarrassing, and yes, we need to do something about it. But is this the way to make that change? I don’t think it is. And the thing I worry about is that, even if we do find what works, we’re so bought into the way we’re doing it now, no one will want to change that.

I’d really like to know what you think.


Author: John Holton

I'm a writer and blogger who writes and blogs about things that interest me.

11 thoughts on “Standardized Confusion”

  1. The testing thing is disturbing. Huge amounts of money are spent on it. Current generations will be learning less in school than they’re parents for the first time in history because schools have to cut things to provide time for testing and practicing for the test.


    1. The common complaint is that there’s never enough money for education, yet the Federal government requires school districts to spend millions of dollars on testing materials each year, probably more than they get from Washington. Kids are either preparing for tests or taking them, and they get no time for recess or “quality of life” classes (e.g. music, art). It’s asinine. At this point, who cares what some NGO says about who are the most accomplished and smartest students in the world? Let kids be kids and enjoy school, and you’ll see improvements.


  2. One of the textbook (not Pearsons!) definitions of insanity is doing the same thing over and over and over again, expecting different results. The federal government seems to be a textbook (again, not Pearsons) example of this, convinced that if they test MORE, they’ll get smarter kids. Not working? Test even MORE! Still not working? MOAR TESTS! It really is ridiculous. And once the government has “invested” so much money into a failing system of testing, they are NOT going to admit they were wrong, but will, instead, dump more and more money into the same non-functional system, in the hope of different results from doing the same thing.
    The federal government is institutionalized insanity.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s